Showing posts with label Board. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Board. Show all posts

December 24, 2014

The National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) Recommends That All States Lower the Per Se DUI Legal Limit From 0.08% BAC to 0.05%

The motivation for the change is to reduce the number of road deaths caused by drinking and driving. According to NTSB estimates, drunk driving accounts for a third of all road deaths.

NTSB Chairman Debbie Hersman said before a vote by the panel on a staff report, "This is critical because impaired driving remains one of the biggest killers in the United States."

Some of the more recent actions that have reduced drinking related deaths are federal and state policies, tougher law enforcement, and stepped up national advocacy. The NTSB staff report estimates, lowering the per se BAC for drinking and driving to .05% would save 500-800 lives annually. In the last 30 years, 440,000 lives have been lost in the United States due to drinking and driving.

Although the individual per se BAC limits are set by individual states, the federal government can be very persuasive convincing states to lower their BAC limit. For instance, the federal government can require such laws before dispersing highway funds.

Not all groups approved of the measure, most notably the American Beverage Institute (ABI). Sarah Longwell, managing director, stated the measure was "ludicrous" and "would criminalize perfectly responsible behavior." Her position is that the NTSB should focus on drivers with higher BAC percentages.

Interestingly, Ms. Longwell refers to MADD as "anti-alcohol activists" and questions whether the science has changed from 10 years ago, when MADD pushed for the .10% BAC standard. This question was not answered, nor was the NTSB number that the move will save 440,000 lives a year explained.

The two positions, between the NTSB and ABI, lacks firm numbers for either of their positions. What is missing is a study that measures the BAC for impaired drivers who were responsible for road collisions resulting in death. The study must be that specific- often when looking at the raw data of studies we find that the stated conclusion does not match the underlying data.

The NTSB also pushed for states to act more proactively in confiscating drivers licenses, installing IIDs for first time offenders, and using "passive alcohol sensors" that can measure alcohol in the air during a traffic stop.

The motivation behind the law is clear- to end drunk driving deaths. However, it is unclear whether the law matches the motivation. That is, without firm data indicating the number of deaths associated with impaired drivers at a certain BAC, then it is a leap of faith, and not data, that justifies lowering the per se limit to save lives.

However, the ABI, and other organizations involved in the hospitality industry, have an interest in keeping patrons comfortable having a drink or two with their meals. Otherwise, they may be too concerned with not creating a criminal record than to have a drink or two.

Mental affects from alcohol affect a person's decision making, including ordering dessert, for instance. From there, the patron may leave a bigger tip, or have one last over-priced after dinner drink. I suppose the perfect per se BAC limit is one which allows for impairment by over-priced alcohol, but does not affect their ability to avoid a church bus on the way home.

The problem with reasonable, scientifically based alcohol legislation is that there is a lot of power in the illogical, emotionally based impacts of drinking and driving victims. The NTSB chose Tuesday, today, to announce the legislation as the 25th Anniversary of the Carrollton Kentucky bus collision which resulted in the deaths of 27 people and 34 more were injured. The bus, which was a modified tour bus from an old school bus, contained members of the Assembly of God church on their way to Kings Island theme park. It is, undeniably, a tragedy.

Careful arguments must be made as the battleground is littered with emotional landmines. I propose that the proper change to save lives does not involve reducing the per se limit of 0.08%, but education to help people understand exactly what it is to be 0.08% BAC, or even a 0.04% BAC. Because regardless of the per se law in 1988, the impaired driver in the Carrollton collision was 0.24% BAC, and a 0.15%, 0.10%, 0.08% or even 0.05% per se law wouldn't have made a lick of difference to those that survived the crash, but were killed by the resulting fire that engulfed the interior of the bus.

Continue Reading...

November 16, 2010

Another DUI with Baby on Board and A Man Faces 3 DUI Charges in One Night

This week’s DUI stories feature a poor parenting decision, and an active night for a man charged with 3 DUIs in a single evening of driving.

It is all too common in the world of DUI news to hear about a parent’s use of poor judgment. Not only do they allegedly drive drunk, but they do so with a child in the car with them.
In Fort Myers, Florida, Brittney Locke is charged with DUI and other crimes, after police say she was stopped on the interstate while driving under the influence, according to ABC 7.
According to police, Locke was stopped after witnesses called police, having witnessed an accident on the highway. The driver left the scene, witnesses said, and police found Locke parked along the side of the road near an exit, with metal sheared off the side of the car.
She also had an infant in the car with her, in a car seat.
Police noted that she appeared to have trouble keeping her eyes open, and said she didn’t know what she’d hit to cause the damage to her car. She failed a field sobriety test.
She claimed to be on the way to see the child’s father, to get money from him. She also told police she was exhausted, and that she had to be up early to visit an area methadone clinic as a part of addiction treatment.
Police allegedly found a Xanex tablet in the car, a prescription bottle of ibuprofen and a plastic straw that, according to ABC, “appeared to be coated with drug residue.”
A relative took control of the child. Locke is charged with DUI, DUI property damage for the guard rail she allegedly hit, child cruelty, drug possession and drug equipment possession.
According to KGMI in Whatcom County, Washington, a man is facing 3 DUI charges after a single night of activity.

Tommy Ryser allegedly wrecked his pickup truck on the road, where police found it at around 8 p.m. on a Monday night. Then, police received a call that another accident had been reported.
It was a red VW Golf that had crashed into a guardrail.
Who pulled up to that accident site but Ryser, driving a tow truck. He had a cut on his face, according to police, and was found to be intoxicated.
According to KGMI, Ryser was arrested for and charged with crashing both disabled vehicles, and with driving drunk to the crash sites, in order to tow them back home.

Continue Reading...

Links

Developed in partnership with SanFran Coders.

Blogroll

The acronyms DUI, DWI, OMVI and OVI all refer to the same thing: operating a vehicle under the influence of alcohol or drugs. The most commonly used terms are DUI, an acronym for Driving Under the Influence, and DWI, an acronym for Driving While Impaired.
© Copyright 2010 - 2015 MY OVI | Developed by San Fran Coders