Showing posts with label Crime. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Crime. Show all posts

March 5, 2015

Scottsdale Crime Lab: The Supreme Court's Statement of Issues

Posted on February 17, 2015 by Lawrence Koplow

Today at 11:00 a.m. the Arizona Supreme Court will hear oral arguments regarding whether to reinstate a trial court's finding that - blood alcohol measurements created by the Scottsdale Crime Lab are unreliable.  You can read a history of this litigation by clicking here.

A case being selected by the Supreme Court for review is a rare event.  Simple math shows it is unlikely that any particular case will be reviewed by the Arizona Supreme Court.   The Court receives a substantial amount of “Petitions” to review lower court decisions, but it only selects a small percentage of them each year.  However, because the issues in this case (it is actually a consolidation of 11 cases) will have wide-ranging consequences, it was an ideal case for the Court to review.  The final ruling by the Court, regardless of who prevails, will likely affect how scientific evidence will be handled by Arizona courts for years to come.

While both parties have their own opinions as to what the key issues are, the Court will provide a summary and statement of the issues from their perspective prior to the oral argument.  Last week, as expected, the Court issued its written statement.  Below are the issues as stated in the Court’s summary:

1. Did the Court err by holding that Rule 702(d) challenges are excluded from judicial gatekeeping scrutiny under Arizona law?

2. Did the Court err in using the accuracy of the results as the criteria for a gatekeeping analysis instead of using the trustworthiness of the methodology used to generate the results?

3. Did the Court err in substituting its own judgment for the trial court’s without finding that the trial court’s decision constituted an abuse of discretion?

After reading this statement of the issues, one could jump to a conclusion from the way the issues are framed, that the Court is leaning in a particular the direction.  A word of caution – no one knows how the court is leaning.  The Court’s final opinion could easily list a different set of issues.

Today’s oral argument is being held at Arizona State University Law School.  The argument is open to the public and starts promptly at 11:00 am.  Everyone is welcome to attend – regardless of which side of the argument you are on.

Trackbacks (0) Links to blogs that reference this article Trackback URL
http://duiblog.arizonaduicenter.com/admin/trackback/319600
Continue Reading...

February 22, 2015

The Scottsdale Crime Lab cases will be reviewed by the Arizona Supreme Court

The Arizona Supreme Court has decided to review the Court of Appeals' (COA) ruling regarding whether Scottsdale DUI results can be trusted.  

Our ongoing legal battle over the defective software used by the Scottsdale Crime Lab (SCL) to measure BAC levels begins its final stage.  The Supreme Court granted our request to review the COA's decision permitting prosecutors to rely upon the measurements generated by this software as a basis for a DUI conviction. 

WHAT HAPPENED?

Over three years ago a few chromatograms (a graphical representation of a blood alcohol measurement) escaped the Scottsdale crime lab (SCL).  It was something we had never seen before. The floodgates of evidence showing forensic malpractice soon opened.  

We learned, that for several years, the SCL had known of serious defects in the software used to measure BACs.  These malfunctions include assigning an incorrect result with the incorrect person (i.e. John gets Fred's result).  No one in the lab had the expertise to explain why this was occurring, or how to "fix" it.  According to an internal email we obtained from the SCL, they "buried" this from the rest of us.

Even after the defense brought this to light, the Prosecution continued to prosecute the public using this unreliable software.  The penalties for those convicted include mandatorily incarceration and significant monetary fines (a portion of which the crime lab receives).  They are currently still using these defective measurements to incarcerate people.

HOW DID WE GET HERE?

There were two primary venues for these debates: 

(1) Superior Court; and 

(2) Scottsdale City Court.  

The Superior Court (felony cases) is where these rulings originated.  The City of Scottsdale courts took a different approach.  That story will be addressed in a separate post.  In the Superior Court, the main case is State v. Herman (on appeal titled In Re Bernstein).  There were two challenges in "Herman" that ended up in the COA.  

Herman #1 (Re: Discovery) 

Because we only had access to the initial documents that appear to have been allowed out of the SCL by accident, we did not know the scope of the problem.  

We convinced two Superior Court Commissioners to hold a joint hearing.  They agreed with our arguments and issued an order to produce all chromatograms from 2011.  The Court also gave the Lab almost two months to provide them.  The deadline came and went.  The SCL admitted they did not even attempt to comply with the order.

We filed a Motion for Contempt.  The prosecution filed a Special Action asking the COA to reverse the order.  The morning before the contempt hearing, the COA stayed everything.   A few months later...

We did not get the data.  Today, the scope of the malfunctions still remains unknown. 

Herman #2 (Re: Reliability) 

After the COA's ruling, we requested a Daubert (reliability) hearing with the trial court.  This would be Arizona's first substantive Daubert hearing (fortunately, the evidence Rules changed in 2012 to permit such a hearing).   Combined, it lasted almost nine (9) months.  To our surprise, we ended up getting material information in the Daubert hearing (Herman #2) that we did not even think to request in Herman #1. 

At the same time, the Arizona Republic started to investigate our claims.  Through their public records requests (and later our own) a treasure trove of damming evidence was obtained.  

At the hearing, SCL personnel were testifying they understood the issues and put forth an “all was well” message.  However, in contrast to their testimony, the Arizona Republic obtained internal emails, that told a much different story than “all is well.”  Their "private" communications showed the court that the SCL personnel testifying, were less than forthcoming about the severity of the problems and their ability to comprehend them.

The combination of SLC personnel’s tainted testimony, and the testimony our forensic experts (including an independent forensic toxicologist, a certified quality assurance lab auditor, a and forensic software engineer), presented a powerful case that the SCL’s measurements and supporting testimony were not trustworthy. 

Arizona Court of Appeals 

As in Herman #1, the prosecution turned to the court of appeals for relief. 

Again, as in Herman #1, it was provided.  

Arizona Supreme Court

Over a year ago, we filed a Petition with the Arizona Supreme Court requesting that they: 

(1) review the court of appeals decision; 

(2) and reinstate the trial court's ruling.

A few weeks ago, the Arizona Supreme Court decided to review the matter.

WHAT'S NEXT.

The Court's decision merely means they granted part one of our request: they will hear the case. They have set oral argument on February 17, 2015 at 11:00 am.  It will be a road game for the Court, as it will be held at ASU Law School.  The oral argument is open to the public, but it is expected to be a full house.  If you want to attend, get there early.

Lawrence Koplow

Continue Reading...

December 18, 2014

DUI and the Constitution. How Driving under the Influence is different than every other crime.

Being arrested for a DUI (Driving under the Influence) is perhaps the most commonly charged criminal offenses in all of Las Vegas.  The reason this crime is so commonly charged is two-fold.  First, law enforcement actively pursues arrests in this type of offense.  While there are no “robbery or rape patrols” there are DUI patrols with special units of officers dedicated to only the arrest of drivers who have been drinking.  Secondly, while most individuals are generally law abiding, there are not many among us who couldn’t have been arrested for driving under the influence at some point in our lives.

So, what happens when you are arrested for DUI?  When law enforcement pulls over a driver and determines that the person behind the wheel is impaired, they are immediately arrested.  In Nevada, when someone is arrested for DUI pursuant to a breath test sample in excess of .08%, the person is not only arrested, but their Nevada Driver’s License is immediately confiscated by the arresting officer and the driver is handed what is commonly called a “pink sheet,” or more precisely a “Officer’s Certification of Cause and Notice of Revocation or Suspension” form.  This paper means two (2) things.  First, it means that the Officer has determined that there is probable cause to arrest the driver, in the form of a breath test in excess of .08%, meaning that (in the officer’s opinion) the driver should lose his or her privilege to drive.   Secondly, this paperwork serves as the driver’s license (remember that the police officer will physically take the driver’s license) for a period of only seven (7) days before the driver’s license is revoked by the DMV.

Most drivers in this position are arrested and given a date to appear for Court following this example.  What many drivers don’t realize however is that this arrest triggers two (2) very difference procedures.  Obviously, this kind of arrest leads to a criminal case in a Court of law… meaning that the driver will face charges and needs a qualified lawyer to represent them in Court.  What many drivers fail to realize however, is at the precise same time (and in most cases earlier) the Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV) will initiate an administrative procedure to revoke the driver’s privileges and ability to drive.

In other words, unlike almost every single other criminal violation, the driver, even though he or she only drove once, is not only prosecuted in the Courts, but he or she is “prosecuted” for driving with a breath alcohol concentration in excess of .08% by the DMV.

While Nevada law dictates that a driver who loses his or her
driving privileges in an administrative DMV proceeding cannot have his or her driving privileges revoked a second time after being convicted criminally for a DUI offense (note that there is a 90 day administrative DMV revocation for a .08% violation for DUI as well as a 90 days revocation for conviction under the criminal statute – – however the driver cannot be revoked twice for both offenses, just one single time) the driver still will face a substantial punishment in the form of classes, victim impact panels, mandatory fines, even jail time.

While in virtually every other situation the constitutions of both the United States and Nevada dictate that a person can only be prosecuted for a single crime once and the 5th amendment of the United States constitution explicitly states that no person shall “be subject for the same offense to be twice put in jeopardy of life and limb,” when it comes to DUI, the constitutional protections of citizens are generally thrown out and ignored by the legislature.

In addition, the laws as they related to DUI offenses in Nevada (and virtually every other state) dictate that when a person is over .08% in their blood or breath, they are “per se” intoxicated.  In Nevada, a person can be arrested, charged and even convicted if their blood or breath sample is over the legal limit, even if they have exhibited no signs of impairment.  However, the driver can still be convicted without ANY forensic sample, from blood, breath or urine showing any level of alcohol in the body.  Unlike almost every other type of criminal allegation, the law says it’s “OK” to prosecute a driver under both theories at the same time.

This dichotomy of allowing a State to punish a driver by two (2) different methods (the DMV proceeding and the Court proceeding) as well as the State’s ability to bring charges in Court by more than one theory, is unique to DUI law.  These difficult issues of law require expert defense.

Because the area of DUI law presents this, and many, many other unique circumstances – coupled with the fact that an arrest and conviction for DUI can lead to permanent consequences for the person convicted, you need to consult with a knowledgeable and experienced DUI Defense attorney right away.  In some cases you only have a week from when you are arrested to save your right to drive and fight your DMV revocation.  Act now and contact us today.  While no criminal case outcome can be guaranteed, at the law firm of Hofland & Tomsheck we have a long track record of achieving positive outcomes for our clients including the reduction and altogether dismissal of DUI charges.  Contact us today and let us start fighting for you.

Continue Reading...

July 27, 2012

More Crime Lab Problems: Philly Lab Tech Flunk Competency Test

and time and time again we find out that these  simple requests are not being met.

THREE TRACE-evidence technicians have flunked a routine test administered to uphold the Philadelphia Police Department crime lab’s accreditation, police brass announced Tuesday.

Each technician tests hundreds of pieces of evidence a year for traces of blood and semen, so if investigators determine that the methods are problematic, it could throw countless court cases into question, authorities acknowledged.

City officials learned of the test failures “within the last 24 hours” and decided to announce them to assure the public that they are moving swiftly to address them, even though they’re fuzzy on many details, said Mike Garvey, director of the crime lab.

The lab has 12 trace examiners; they’re tested by an outside agency twice a year, six at a time, to ensure their competency. Although just half of the six most recently tested failed, the agency that administers the test hasn’t yet told the city which three flubbed it. They’re expected to do so by early June.

Until then, Garvey said, all six have been removed from their trace-examination duties. Once the three are identified, they will be retrained. Authorities will reexamine every case they handled, Garvey said. All six examiners tested are veterans, and until now none of the lab’s 12 trace technicians has failed a test since at least 2004, Garvey added. The 12 technicians handle about 3,000 cases a year.

“We don’t have all the answers yet,” Police Commissioner Charles Ramsey said. “This is just starting.”

Garvey added: “It’s the right call, if there’s any question [about accuracy].”

Tuesday’s announcement comes about a year after police officials announced another embarrassing flub — miscalibrated Breathalyzer machines — that threw more than 1,100 drunken-driving cases into limbo. The goof prompted the District Attorney’s Office to review thousands of ongoing cases and even retry some.

Tasha Jamerson, spokeswoman for the District Attorney’s Office, said that so many details remain unknown about how or why the examiners flunked the test that she couldn’t comment on how it would impact ongoing court cases. n

Contact Dana DiFilippo at difilid@phillynews.com or 215-854-5934. Read her blog at phillyconfidential.com.

In cases like DUI where the crime lab reports make up the bulk of the evidence against the accused, these kinds of failures threaten many people with false DUI convictions. The problem is rampant and widespread.  I have witnessed numerous cases in Pennsylvania where blood tests have been proven to be scientifically invalid because the science was not there. It was not valid. It was not reliable.

Stay tuned to the happenings in Philly…I have a feeling we have only scratched the surface.


View the original article here

Continue Reading...

February 2, 2011

Boston’s Appeals Court Overturns Sex Crime Conviction In Prostitution Case Involving A Juvenile- Attorney Sam’s Take


Samuel Goldberg has been a Massachusetts criminal defense attorney for 20 years. Prior to that, he was a New York state prosecutor. He has published various articles regarding the practice of criminal law and frequently provides legal analysis on radio and television, appearing on outlets such as the Fox News Channel, Court TV, MSNBC and The BBC Network.
To speak to Sam about a criminal matter call 617-492-3000.

Posted On: January 12, 2011 by Samuel Goldberg

Here’s one for the sex trade! In the past, we have discussed many times the various, and in my opinion, faulty rationales for keeping prostitution illegal. One of those rationales has been that prostitutes are, per se, victims. They are exploited and forced to perform sex acts for money. The thought seems to have been that being a prostitute is definitional of losing one’s will and performing the evil deeds by force.

Well, the Massachusetts Appeals Court has ruled against this equation. It has thrown out the convictions of a pimp and a madam (hereinafter, the “Defendants”), ruling that the couple did not lure a homeless and drug-addicted teenager into prostitution because the 16-year-old runaway had sold her body for money in the past.

The court did, however, let stand the Defendants’ convictions for deriving support from prostitution and contributing to the delinquency of a minor.

The allegations in the case were that the Defendants drove the teen to the hotel where she met an undercover detective and agreed to engage in sex for $280, according to court records. Using a ruse, the officer convinced the teen to leave the hotel before any sexual acts occurred. The teen then apparently handed the cash the Defendants, who were waiting in the hotel parking lot

The court found, “We think that the language of the statute is plain and unambiguous and that it clearly expresses the Legislature's intent to penalize a person for inducing a minor, who is not then so engaged, to engage in the commercial enterprise of prostitution by offering for hire his or her body for indiscriminate sexual activity’’.

As a Boston sex crimes criminal defense attorney for over twenty years, not to mention previous years as a prosecutor, I have been involved in a number of cases involving prostitution.

I agree that it is worth prosecuting those who force anyone into prostitution, or aid children in engaging in the trade is worthwhile. However, the attempts to combat those situations are diluted and tainted when we open the broad scope of assuming that every prostitute is a victim and must be saved from themselves, if not everyone else. In fact, it perverts the very effort of female dignity assuming that a woman could never make such a choice herself with sound reason.

In this case, the Appeals Court did not make new law or break new ground. It did, however, enforce the law as it was meant when it was written, rather than simply cave in to public sentiment.

Playing the devil’s advocate (something most people would say I do every day in my line of work), there is an interesting argument that could be made against the court’s ruling. As you know, in matters sexual, we tend to believe that a minor cannot consent to sex. Under the law, it does not even matter if the sex-mate knows that the minor is under age. In fact, it does not even matter if the minor lied and “proved” she was of age.

Sex with a minor, with or without her preferred consent, is rape. Pure and simple.

Couldn’t one argue that, since the prostitute here was a minor, she had to be induced, because any participation with her in the sex trade is manipulating her because she has no ability to consent?

After all, under the law, any customer who had sex with a minor should be not only guilty of prostitution, but also rape.

Just saying…..!

The language and rationale of the laws and how our law enforcement agencies choose to implement them is a pretty thick and, often, confusing forest.

This is why you need an experienced criminal defense attorney to help light your way through it.

If you would like to discuss my lighting your way, please feel to call me to arrange a free initial consultation at 617-492-3000.

To view the original story in which parts of this blog were based, please go to : http://www.boston.com/news/local/breaking_news/2011/01/by_john_r_ellem_29.html


View the original article here

Continue Reading...

Links

Developed in partnership with SanFran Coders.

Blogroll

The acronyms DUI, DWI, OMVI and OVI all refer to the same thing: operating a vehicle under the influence of alcohol or drugs. The most commonly used terms are DUI, an acronym for Driving Under the Influence, and DWI, an acronym for Driving While Impaired.
© Copyright 2010 - 2015 MY OVI | Developed by San Fran Coders