Showing posts with label Dismissed. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Dismissed. Show all posts

March 27, 2015

MOTORCYCLIST WITH NO ALCOHOL IN HIS BLOOD WAITS FIVE MONTHS BEFORE DUI CHARGE IS DISMISSED

In September of 2014, CW was driving his motorcycle in northwestern New York and collided with another motorcycle. A police officer responded to the accident scene and reportedly noticed the odor of alcohol on CW. The officer asked CW to take a breath test, and CW refused. The officer ultimately obtained a blood sample from CW and charged him with DWI (known as OVI in Ohio). The officer then sent the blood sample to be tested. The test revealed a blood alcohol content of 0.00. Last week, five months after CW was charged with DWI, the case was finally dismissed, as reported by the Genesee Sun.

Blood draw

If this case occurred in Ohio, it would have likely gone through the same process. When an officer in Ohio suspects a driver is under the influence, the officer requests a breath test, blood test, or urine test. In cases where a blood test or urine test is used, the results of the test are not immediately known to the officer. Despite not having the test results, officers routinely charge people with OVI immediately after the blood or urine sample is obtained. The blood or urine sample is then sent to a laboratory for analysis, and the analysis typically is not completed until weeks or months after the person is charged.

In cases involving blood/urine tests, there are two types of OVI charges which may be filed. First, the suspect is charged with OVI ‘impaired’. The ‘impaired’ charge accuses the suspect of operating a vehicle with driving ability impaired by alcohol and/or drugs. The ‘impaired’ charge is not dependent on the results of a blood/urine/breath test. Second, if the test results show an alcohol or drug level at or above the prohibited concentration (the ‘legal limit’), the suspect is charged with OVI ‘per se’. The ‘per se’ charge accuses the suspect of operating a vehicle with a prohibited alcohol or drug level. The ‘per se’ charge does not depend on whether suspect’s ability to drive was impaired.

In the case of CW, the officer likely charged CW with DWI ‘impaired’ on the day of the accident. If the blood test revealed an alcohol level above .080, CW would have also been charged with DWI ‘per se’. As the blood test revealed there was no alcohol in CW’s blood, CW was never charged with DWI ‘per se’.

It was appropriate for the prosecutor to dismiss the ‘impaired’ charge. I suppose the prosecutor could have maintained the charge and tried to prove CW’s ability to drive was impaired by alcohol. Doing so could end badly for the prosecutor, as rules of professionalism require a prosecutor to seek the truth and only pursue a charge when the charge is supported by probable cause.

Probable cause is also the standard for an officer to file charges. The blood test result makes me wonder what evidence the officer observed before charging CW with DWI. The report by the Genesee Sun references the odor of alcohol but does not mention any evidence indicating CW was under the influence. It does mention his refusal of the breath test, but that is not necessarily evidence he was under the influence: it may be evidence he was justifiably indignant about the officer’s request.

Charging people with OVI without test results can have unfortunate consequences, as it did for CW. Hopefully he will have the case sealed so there is no public record he was even charged with DWI. Having the public records sealed, however, does not undo the embarrassment he experienced when he was arrested or the anxiety he experienced for five months while the case was pending.

Continue Reading...

January 12, 2015

Can I get my Deferred Prosecution be dismissed early?

THE DUISEATTLE.COM BLOG : Can I get my Deferred Prosecution be dismissed early? THE DUISEATTLE.COM BLOG Your Community Resource for DUI and Criminal Traffic Defense in Washington State. Writings of Seattle DUI Lawyer and Seattle Criminal Lawyer W. James Kotlowski. A Discussion of Washington State DUI, Physical Control, Reckless Driving, Negligent Driving, Deferred Prosecution, Department of Licensing and Criminal Traffic Law Issues. 20 years of experience. Call or Text - 206.335.2422 for a Free Consultation. HomeArchivesProfileSubscribe Lawyer Walter Kotlowski | Top Attorney DUI W James Kotlowski Attorney at Law PLLC, Attorneys - DUI, Seattle, WA How many days do I have to appeal a DOL Decision?How many Jurors will be in my DUI Trial?Do DUI attorneys offer monthly payment plans?Will my Seattle PD DUI arrest be recorded?Can I record the DOL Hearing?Can I do another deferred - if for mental health?Will I get an occupational license or an Ignition Interlock License?Can I get my Deferred Prosecution be dismissed early?A day to be Thankful and ResponsibleWill I receive credit for SCRAM? Search OFFICEContact Information
Law Office of W. James Kotlowski PLLC 1411 Fourth Avenue,Suite 1130Seattle, Washington 98101 Tel: (206) 395-2004james@duiseattle.com www.DUISeattle.com
FREE ONLINE CASE EVALUATION
December 2014 Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat   1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31       AboutDISCLAIMERPLEASE NOTE:This blog is made available by the lawyer publisher for educational purposes only as well as to give information and a general understanding of the law, not to provide specific legal advice. By using this blog site you understand that there is no attorney client relationship between you and the Blog publisher. The linked sites are not under the control of the Law Office of W. James Kotlowski PLLC and the Office is not responsible for the contents of any linked site. The Blog should not be used as a substitute for competent legal advice from a licensed professional attorney in your state. W. James Kotlowski is licensed to practice law in the State of Washington only.ArchivesDecember 2014November 2014October 2014September 2014August 2014July 2014June 2014May 2014April 2014March 2014More...

Categories20 day hearing notice2012 Boating opening day2013 Boating Under the Influence2nd deferred prosecution60 days ABOUT THE AUTHORAlcohol ReportAlcohol/Drug EvaluationalcoholismArraignmentAttorney FeesBAC LimitBailBail Bond CompanyBail HearingBoating chargesBoating under the influenceBreath Test RecordsBUICanadaChanges to the Law Choosing an AttorneyCommunity Serviceconditions of releaseCost of DUICourt CostsCourt ProcessCourt Recordscoverage areaCriminal History (DCH)Current AffairsCustodydeferred prosecutiondeferred sentenceDifferences in JurisdictionDifferent JurisdictionsDOL administrative hearingDOL HearingDOL IssuesDOL SubpoenasDraegerDrivers LicenseDriving TestDUI arrestDUI arrest DUI arrest videoDUI BailDUI BlogsDUI Deferred ProsecutionDUI filingDUI JailDUI newsDUI Payment PlansDUI preventive measuresDUI ProbationDUI Probation violationsDWLS/3EHDEHMEmergency Vehicles Employer ExemptionevidenceExpert Expunge DUIFelony DUIfinesGamesHelpful TipsHiring an attorneyHit & RunIgnition Interlock LicenseIIDIILImmigration ConsequencesIMPOUNDImpound LawInterstate drivers license compactinvestigationJailjurisdictionJurorsJury Trialmental health deferredMissed DOL Hearing NVOLOccupational LicenseOfficeOne a lifetimeonline case evaluationPayment PlansPBTPlea BargainPractical TipsPre-arrestpre-trial hearingsPrescription DrugsProbable Cause to StopProbable Cause to Stop ProbationProbation Probation OfficerPunched LicensequestionsRALJReckless DrivingReinstate LicenseRelapseRestricted Licenserevoked deferred prosecutionRight to AttorneyRoad BlocksSCRAMSeattle Municipal CourtSentencingSentencing OptionsSOCSOLSPDSpecial Series: DUI 2012 Law ChangesSR-22 InsuranceState ID statementsStatementssuspension period expirestalk to policeTow feesTracking InfractionsTraffic SchoolTravelTravel to CanadaTreatmentVacate DUIVacate recordvideoviolation of conditions or releasewaiveWarrantsWashington State DUI NewsWashington State Ferry WitnessesDUI NewsNew award recognizes DUI officers doing exceptional work | www.kirotv.com
This victim impact panel is for young people charged with DUI - Chicago Tribune
http://www.kvewtv.com/article/2014/jul/18/summer-kick-dui-patrol-results-released/
Funding shortage could put DUI drivers back on road - NBC News
App-based ridesharing a possible DUI game-changer | Regional Voices | The News Tribune
Extra DUI patrols to remind drivers of Federal Way teens killed by drunk driver - Federal Way Mirror
Colorado launches campaign to stop stoned driving - Yahoo TV
Man blows 0.00 on breathalyzer, gets arrested for DWI | Odd News - Yahoo News
No Easy Answers For DUI Concerns As Marijuana Gains Support : NPR
Repeat DUI offenders to get strict monitoring in Chelan County
WASHINGTON STATE DUI LEGAL RESOURCES AA Meetings
Alcohol Drug Evaluation (Seattle Metro)
Alcohol Ignition Interlock Device
Alcohol/Drug Treatment (Western WA)
Alcohol/Drug Treatment (payment plans available)
Court Date: Seattle Municipal Court
Court Date: Washington State Courts
Criminal Record: Washington State Patrol
DOL Driver License Questions
DOL Driver Licensing forms
Driver License Status: Real Time
DUI Victims Panel
ECR -King County District Court
Ignition Interlock License Application
Insurance SR 22
Issaquah Jail and Inmate Info
King County District Court
King County District Court Online Payments
Lynnwood Municipal Online Payments
Traffic School: NTSI
Vacate Traffic Conviction Record
Vern Fonk Insurance (SR-22)
Warrant? Procedures - King County District Court
Washington Snohomish County Jail Register
Washington State, King County Jail Register
CELEBRITY DUISManziel’s bodyguard arrested for DUI, while driving Manziel’s car | ProFootballTalk
Snooki's Husband Jionni LaValle Pleads Guilty to DUI After Wedding - Us Weekly
Rapper Xzibit Arrested for Alleged DUI Shortly After Getting Married - Yahoo
Amanda Bynes pleads no contest to 'wet reckless' in DUI case - latimes.com
Justin Bieber Reportedly Rejects DUI Plea Deal | Celebrity-gossip.net
Justin Bieber DUI Case Update: Plea Deal Rejected | ExtraTV.com
Vikings LB Henderson arrested again for DWI - Yahoo Sports
Motion to dismiss Marshawn Lynch DUI case denied | Seattle Seahawks | The Olympian
Lisa Robin Kelly of 'That '70s Show' arrested on suspicion of DUI - latimes.com
Amanda Bynes Is "Fine," Reports in NY "Exaggerated," Says Lawyer : People.com
DAILY READINGCapitol Hill Times | Serving Capitol Hill and First Hill Since 1926 - Seattle, WA
Dallas Morning News
Front | Tri-City Herald : Mid-Columbia news
Madison Park Times | Serving East-Central Seattle Since 1983 - Seattle, WA
Melbourne Herald Sun
New York Times
Politico.com
Queen Anne & Magnolia News - Seattle, WA
Redmond Reporter - Local News, Sports, Entertainment
Saint John Telegraph Journal
Subscribe to this blog's feedLEGAL REFERENCE Arizona Criminal Lawyer and Phoenix DUI Laws and Criminal Defense
bulk.resource.org
Business.gov - Official Business Link to the U.S. Government
Data.Seattle.Gov | Seattle's Data Site
General Name Change Information
King County Bar Association
Law Dictionary
Legal Research, Casemaker
Oregon Revised Statutes
Oregon State Bar
OTHER LEGAL BLOGS/SITES Avvo Blog
Civl Litigation Attorney
Employment Law Blog
Family Law: Collaborative Divorce (Eastern Washington)
Index of Legal Blogs
Professional Licensing Issues
Real Estate/Estate Planning Attorney
« A day to be Thankful and Responsible |Main| Will I get an occupational license or an Ignition Interlock License? »

November 28, 2014 Can I get my Deferred Prosecution be dismissed early?No. Notwithstanding, your completing alcohol/drug treatment ahead of schedule. (you started treatment before entering deferred prosecution in Court - not unusual) According to Washington State law the earliest your DUI can be dismissed is 5 years from the date of entering or acceptance of the deferred prosecution by the Court. 

Posted at 04:32 PM in DUI Deferred Prosecution | Permalink

Reblog (0)

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00e553da03ec883301b7c70a753f970b

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Can I get my Deferred Prosecution be dismissed early?:

THE DUISEATTLE.COM BLOG Powered by Typepaddocument.write(unescape("%3Cscript src='" + (document.location.protocol == "https:" ? "https://sb" : "http://b") + ".scorecardresearch.com/beacon.js'%3E%3C/script%3E"));COMSCORE.beacon({ c1: 2, c2: "6035669", c3: "", c4: "http://duiseattleblog.typepad.com/dui_seattle/2014/11/can-i-fia-deferred-prosecution-be-dismissed-early.html", c5: "", c6: "", c15: ""});
Continue Reading...

December 7, 2014

DUI Charges Dismissed for Driver Who Ran a Yellow Light

I’m always pleased when I read about the court and prosecutors recognizing that police must adhere to the Constitution in investigating crimes. I can say with first-hand knowledge that this, unfortunately, is a rare occurrence for many individuals arrested on suspicion of DUI. Jesse R. White of Charleston, Illinois who was arrested and charged with driving under the influence is one of the lucky few where justice prevailed.

White was stopped because, according to the arresting Eastern Illinois University police officer, he ran a red light. The traffic stop led the officer to believe that White was driving under the influence. And, in fact, White was subsequently arrested for felony drunk driving charges because White had suffered prior DUI convictions. 

In one of my first posts for duiblog.com, I explained why I unreservedly agree with law enforcement equipping squad cars with “dash-cams.” The article can be found here:  https://www.duiblog.com/2014/04/25/the-use-of-dash-cams-in-dui-stops-2/. The gist of it is that dash-cams (also called MVARS) are an objective capturing of the evidence, unlike the arresting officer’s memory of the events. What’s more, unlike officers, dash-cams can’t lie.

Fortunately for White, the officer who arrested him had a dash-cam attached to his vehicle. A review of the dash-cam video revealed that White had actually run a yellow light, not a red light as the officer had claimed. As such, the officer had absolutely no reason to pull White over.

The United States Supreme Court has held that law enforcement can initiate a traffic stop if they have reasonable suspicion, based on specific and articulable facts, to believe that an offense has occurred. In fact, on several other occasions, the United States Supreme Court has even held that where an officer has observed a traffic violation, the higher standard of probable cause is met.

Without reasonable suspicion, the traffic stop is illegal and any evidence obtain as a result of the illegal traffic stop is inadmissible as evidence.

Because White had only run a yellow light, not a red light, the arresting officer had no reasonable suspicion that White had committed any offense, thus making the stop illegal. Therefore, the evidence obtained as a result of the illegal stop, presumably the telltale signs of intoxication (bloodshot eyes, distinct odor or alcohol, slurred speech), are inadmissible in a DUI trial.

White’s attorney filed a motion to suppress the evidence arguing exactly this.

At the hearing on the motion to suppress the evidence, the judge dismissed the charges against White after the prosecutor, Coles County State’s Attorney Brian Bower, viewed the dash-cam footage and agreed with the motion.

While Bower was correct in agreeing with the motion, he was wrong in justifying the officer’s stop of White’s vehicle. According to Bower, the officer didn’t do anything wrong and likely saw the red light after it had changed from yellow.

Okay, so either the officer made a mistake or was lying about the red light. Either way, at trial the officer would have testified that White had run the red light. Without other evidence, like a dash-cam, how else are we to determine whether White ran the red light? Unfortunately, we can’t.

How many others have been stopped or arrested when the officer was mistaken, or worse, lied about whether a traffic violation occurred?

Share This entry was posted on Monday, November 10th, 2014 at 7:22 am and is filed under Duiblog. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can skip to the end and leave a response. Pinging is currently not allowed.

Continue Reading...

Links

Developed in partnership with SanFran Coders.

Blogroll

The acronyms DUI, DWI, OMVI and OVI all refer to the same thing: operating a vehicle under the influence of alcohol or drugs. The most commonly used terms are DUI, an acronym for Driving Under the Influence, and DWI, an acronym for Driving While Impaired.
© Copyright 2010 - 2015 MY OVI | Developed by San Fran Coders