Showing posts with label Operation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Operation. Show all posts

December 11, 2014

What constitutes "Operation" for DUI purposes in Kentucky?

PictureDon't sleep and drive! It is not every day that you get a client who is being charged with a DUI while they were sleeping in their vehicle. Now that begs the questions, can you really be guilty of a DUI if the vehicle was not moving and you were unconscious or sleeping, even though you were located in the driver's seat?

Various states across the country have their own definitions for what constitutes person's operation of a motor vehicle for purposes of the DUI statutes. Some states define it as "driving," while others, use terms like "operation," and "actual physical control."

But what about Kentucky? -- Well, I'm glad you asked!

In Kentucky, the DUI statute KRS 189a.010(1) begins as follows: "A person shall not operate or be in physical control of a motor vehicle anywhere in this state[.]" That is quite vague. What do those words mean? Well, unluckily, Kentucky courts have not defined those terms, but what they have done is given us some guidelines as to what constitutes physical control and operation.

The controlling case is Wells v. Commonwealth, 709 S.W.2d 847 (Ky. App. 1986). It outlines the four factors a court must look at in order to determine whether or not a person operated or was in actual physical control of a motor vehicle. The factors are:

(1) whether or not the person in the vehicle was asleep or awake; 
(2) whether or not the motor was running; 
(3) the location of the vehicle and all of the circumstances bearing on how
the vehicle arrived at that location; and 
(4) the intent of the person behind the wheel.

Basically, it is a totality of the circumstances analysis. The court will look at the factors above along with any other facts and circumstances, and determine whether or not that constitutes "operation" or "physical control." 

In my current sleeping driver case, the key was turned to the 'on' position with the engine running and her headlights were on (that's why the officer presumably decided to investigate the scene.) It was a cold February night, and she wanted to stay warm in her vehicle. She was not intoxicated and there were no field sobriety tests done nor does the Commonwealth have an Intoxilyzer result.

So why in the world is she being charged with a DUI?! Good question, dear reader. Results remain to be seen. The facts are great, the argument appears flawless, now it's up to the prosecutor to dismiss the case.

Thanks for readin' and God bless.

If you require assistance with a DUI, expungement, traffic ticket, or other criminal charges, please contact me or call me at (270) 945-2778.

The DUI Guy

Continue Reading...

February 26, 2011

Malden Armed Robbery Sting Operation Yields Three Arrests – Attorney Sam’s Take

Sting operations in Massachusetts are not uncommon. They are employed by law enforcement to investigate various types of crimes from drug dealing to prostitution.

Oh yes. And guns.

Robert C. Kenney, 56, Christopher P. Littlejohn, 30, and Ramone Arakelow, 34, all from Beverly, (collectively, the “Defendants”) have now learned this lesson. They were arrested last week in such an operation. They allegedly thought they were planning a home invasion in Malden with “legitimate” co-conspirators.

The victim-to-be was a drug dealer.

The victim-to-be was not a legal citizen.

The victim- to be…did not exist.

The would-be victim was simply part of a fictitious scenario created by authorities who had been investigating the Defendants. What the various law enforcement agencies (FBI, State Police and various local police departments) were really after was weapons. One of the Defendants is suspected of selling seven illegal firearms in the Boston and North Shore areas, State Police said. The other two are suspected associates.

The authorities monitored the Defendants as they made their way along Route 99 in a green and gray pickup truck. A State Police helicopter was also tracking the truck. When the truck stopped in Saugus, allegedly the spot used to prepare for the night’s festivities, they were arrested.

Inside the truck, authorities say they found knives, a ski mask, duct tape, and paraphernalia indicating the men planned to pose as federal immigration agents during the home invasion, including a fluorescent jacket like those worn by police officers, emergency lights that could be mounted on a dashboard, and zip ties, used by police as handcuffs.

The Defendants face a host of charges, ranging from conspiracy to commit armed robbery in state court and, potentially, gun charges in federal court.

As a long time experience criminal defense attorney in Boston, I have often criticized police officers for not for being creative and not limiting themselves to the truth. There are, however, Cases in which police officers are creative, manipulating the truth, but simply doing their jobs.

This would include sting operations such as that which is mentioned in today's story.

"But Sam, isn't this entrapment?"

No it is probably not. It might be entrapment if officers enticed an individual who would never otherwise commit such a crime to commit it. This does not seem to be the case in this story.

I have often reminded you that, in the course of the investigation, police officers are allowed to lie for a number of reasons. We have discussed times where officers lie to suspect in order to get statements from him or to trick him into letting the officers into his home. They are also allowed to actais undercover officers and trick people whmo they believe would otherwise commit a crime pretend to join in the fun with them.

Far from finding this unfair, the law considers this "good police work". When the case involves people who might otherwise do home invasions or possess weapons, the law is particularly pleased with the police manipulations.

"Well I know that people are not allowed to lie to police officers, that is a felony, right?"

Yes, that's right.

"But then isn't it unfair that they were allowed to lie to us?"

Perhaps it is unfair, but it is the state of the law. After all, these are police officers and it is assumed that they are always acting for the public good. They are, after all, protecing us.

The rest of us are apparently not so laudable. So, trying to save your own skin, or that of a loved one, is not a good enough reason to lie.

You do have the right to keep your mouth closed, though. Usually, when contacted in an investigation, the wise thing is to do just that until you have a chance to contact an experienced criminal defense attorney. Especially if the person being investigated is you.

You may or may not end up cooperating with police. But making that decision alone can cost you years in the end.

The part of reality that the system does not seem to recognize is that, good or bad, after a certain point in an investigation, the officers decide what they believe the truth to be. By the time they get to interviewing you, little you say is likely to convince them that they were wrong.

If you would like it discuss a criminal matter with me, please feel free to call me to arrange a free initial consultation at 617-492-3000.

In the meantime, have a great Valentine's day!

To view the original story, please go to : http://www.boston.com/news/local/breaking_news/2011/02/three_beverly_m.html


View the original article here

Continue Reading...

Links

Developed in partnership with SanFran Coders.

Blogroll

The acronyms DUI, DWI, OMVI and OVI all refer to the same thing: operating a vehicle under the influence of alcohol or drugs. The most commonly used terms are DUI, an acronym for Driving Under the Influence, and DWI, an acronym for Driving While Impaired.
© Copyright 2010 - 2015 MY OVI | Developed by San Fran Coders