An attorney in Florida has recently proposed a tactic that drivers can use to avoid questioning at a DUI checkpoint. Boca Raton attorney Warren Redlich suggests using a sign like the one he is holding. He has made a YouTube video, which has gone viral, showing how it works .
But could this method work in Pennsylvania? CBS 21 Harrisburg recently asked Attorney Richard Roberts of The McShane Firm:
HARRISBURG, Pa.– A Florida attorney got national attention after he tried going through a DUI checkpoint without saying a word. That attorney said all a driver needs to do is show the officer a sign and a license through a closed window. But is this method acceptable in Pennsylvania?
Video of a DUI checkpoint in Florida last New Year’s Eve went viral. In the video police wave a driver through without asking him to roll down his window. One may wonder if someone can actually get away with that?
The man behind the wheel in the video is Florida Attorney Warren Redlich. He says this is a way to protect a driver’s rights at a DUI checkpoint; it’s not however, designed to allow drunk drivers through the checkpoints.
Michelle Haselrig of Harrisburg doesn’t agree with this tactic one iota.
“That would hurt somebody; get into a car accident when they could have stopped them. I don’t think people should start doing this at all. Just go through the checkpoints,” Haselrig said.
How feasible is this method in Pennsylvania? Harrisburg DUI attorney Richard Roberts has the answers.
“Simply because you refuse to roll down your window, simply because you refuse to speak to the officer does not give them grounds to stop you,” Roberts said.
It is by rights that one can keep their window up at a check point as long as you provide a visible license and registration, but it’s not advised.
“You are drawing attention to yourself, so you understood that anytime you assert your rights there are probably some risks with people who think you’re doing the wrong thing,” Roberts said.
Studies have found that DUI checkpoints reduced alcohol related crashes by about nine percent.
comments



Topics DUI (99) DUI Checkpoints (45) Celebrity DUI (2) DUI Field Sobriety Tests (16) Ignition Interlock Device (11) DUI Trials (2) DUI Program (24) Felony (6) Dry Reckless (1) DMV Administrative Hearings (10) Suspended Driver's License (51) Negligent Operator (4) San Francisco DMV DUI suspension (1) Oakland DMV license suspension (1) Santa Rosa DMV license suspension (1) Traffic Ticket Defense (32) Red Light Camera Tickets (11) Speeding Tickets (23) Hit and Run (1) Cell Phone and Texting Tickets (2) Criminal Defense (12) Sex Offenses (1) Assault and Battery (6) Batter on a Police Officer Battery on a Police Officer (2) Marijuana (2) Drunk in Public (1) Vandalism (1) Theft Crimes (5) Felony (8) Drug Possession (6) Child Endangerment (5) Domestic Violence (2) Evading a Police Officer (2) Trespassing (1) Resisting Arrest (2) Conspiracy (2) Embezzlement (1) Misdemeanor (5) Domestic Violence (1) Car Theft (2) Probation Violation (3) Felony (4) Drug Possession (2) Child Endangerment (1) Probation (8) Evading a Police Officer (1) NHTSA (7) Robbery (1) Drug Crimes (3) Under the Influence of a Controlled Substance (1) Speed Trap (1) Recent Entries
Main Office:
In an effort to frighten would-be drunken drivers into acting responsibly at Halloween-themed parties this weekend, DUI checkpoints will be set up on three roadways in the midstate.
A photo at the June 15 DUI checkpoint protest by the Valley Forge Revolutionaries. Credit Photo courtesy of Valley Forge Revolutionaries
Monroe County Courthouse (Image credit Doug Kerr, on Flickr)
It’s ironic and sad that while we celebrate our independence from imperial tyranny in the state where the Declaration of Interdependence was signed, we, the common citizens still face these humiliating assaults on our liberty. We are subject to unwarranted searches and treated like criminals by the government and police who hide behind the facade of “DUI Enforcement.” Their real motivation has nothing to do with the public good, rather these checkpoints are a cash cow for police departments. They are compromising our independence and disregarding the spirit of our Founding Fathers to satisfy their own greed.
Whatcha gonna do when they come for you?
If the road looks like this, pull over.
Orange County DUI Checkpoint Locations
Don't finish the tray before heading into an Orange County DUI Checkpoint
Orange County DUI Checkpoint in Costa Mesa announced
The famous "black and white" LAPD police cruiser (Photo credit: Wikipedia)
Police in Pennsylvania are gearing up for more DUI checkpoints over the holidays.