Showing posts with label DWI. Show all posts
Showing posts with label DWI. Show all posts

December 6, 2014

DUI, DWI case of Fruitland Police Chief Michael Phillips set for Monday in Princess Anne.

The impaired driving case of Fruitland Police Chief Michael Phillips will go to trial Monday, said defense attorney John Phoebus.
"We're looking forward to our day in court," Phoebus said Wednesday.
Phillips, 48, of Salisbury faces charges of driving while under the influence of alcohol and driving while impaired by alcohol, along with a charge of following vehicle too closely.
A Somerset County sheriff's deputy stopped Phillips' personal vehicle at about 10:25 p.m. June 29 on northbound Route 13 at Somerset Avenue outside Princess Anne, online court records state.
Phillips' trial is scheduled for 9 a.m. Monday. The case is in District Court in Princess Anne, which means it will be a judge trial –– not a jury trial.
A special prosecutor has been assigned to the case: Jonathan Naylor, traffic safety resource prosecutor with the Maryland State's Attorneys Association in Ellicott City. A petition to appoint special counsel from Somerset County Deputy State's Attorney Edmund Widdowson was made since Phillips is Fruitland's police chief and a retired Maryland State Police trooper who worked in Somerset County.
Naylor said Thursday he would not be able to speak about facts of the case prior to a trial.
Phoebus wrote in a statement June 30 that Phillips asked to be placed on paid administrative leave until the case is resolved, and the Fruitland City Council agreed. He wrote this wasn't an admission of guilt by Phillips, but what would be standard procedure for any Fruitland officer.
Fruitland City Manager John Psota wrote in an emailed statement July 1 there would not be an interim chief taking Phillips' place during the paid administrative leave.
Phoebus said Wednesday that he was not in a position to say whether Phillips would or would not testify at the trial.

Continue Reading...

December 1, 2014

Commonwealth's attorney bonds out of jail following arrested for DUI

Virginia Peninsula Regional Jail said that Surry County Commonwealth's Attorney Gerald Poindexter bonded out of jail late Saturday or early Sunday, following his arrest for Driving Under the Influence.
James City County police officers took Poindexter into custody at the Jamestown Ferry Dock shortly after 3:30 p.m. Saturday. Ferry officials called them to report a minor car crash involving an intoxicated driver.
Police said that driver was 73-year-old Poindexter and that he hit a curb while getting on the ferry on the Surry County side of the James River.
Ferry attendants tried to stop him from continuing to board, but told officers Poindexter drove onto the ferry and hit another vehicle, causing minor damage.
Officials suspected Poindexter was under the influence of alcohol.
Besides facing a DUI charge, Poindexter faces a charge for No Driver's License in Possession.
He was being held on a $2,500 unsecured bond before his release.
Continue Reading...

UA receiver Samajie Grant cited on suspicion of DUI

Arizona Wildcats wide receiver Samajie Grant was cited on suspicion of driving under the influence early Saturday morning, hours after helping the UA to a 42-35 win over rival Arizona State.
Grant will not start in Friday's Pac-12 Championship game against Oregon, coach Rich Rodriguez said in a statement to the Star on Saturday evening.
"We were notified earlier today of an issue involving Samajie Grant. After communicating with Samajie, local law enforcement and our athletics administration, we've decided that the appropriate form of action is to make sure Samajie receives counseling and takes part in community-service activities," Rodriguez said. "We're disappointed in Samajie's decision-making, but we expect this to be an isolated incident and he won't be starting in the Pac-12 Championship game."
Grant failed a field sobriety test, said Deputy Tom Peine, a spokesman for the Pima County Sheriff's Department. Grant cooperated with authorities and was cited and released at the scene, Peine said. Grant was pulled over by a deputy on the DUI enforcement unit that was patrolling the area of North Campbell Avenue and East Sixth Street, Peine said.
The deputy noticed a Chevrolet Camaro traveling west on Sixth Street and turning north onto Campbell, Peine said. The deputy observed a vehicle with the license plate lights not working and observed behavior of a possibly impaired driver, he said.
The deputy conducted a traffic stop near Campbell and East Third Street and noted seven people in the vehicle. He also smelled marijuana from the car, Peine said.
Grant was identified as the driver and was asked to exit the vehicle, Peine said.
After failing the field sobriety test, probable cause was found to cite and release Grant for driving under the influence of drugs, minor in possession of spirituous liquor, person under 21 in physical control of a motor vehicle with spirituous liquor, and driving without a valid operator's license, Peine said.
The vehicle was impounded because Grant didn't have a driver's license, Peine said.
Grant, a sophomore from Compton, California, had four catches for 91 yards and two touchdowns in Arizona's win over Arizona State.
UA athletic director Greg Byrne said the athletic department was made aware of the incident Saturday.
"We've been in contact with Samajie and local law enforcement has informed us that he was cooperative during the process," Byrne said. "We're extremely disappointed in Samajie and he will be undergoing counseling and taking part in community service as a result of his actions."
Continue Reading...

Connecticut State Police report 665 accidents, 25 DUI arrests during holiday enforcement

Connecticut State Police say they've responded to 665 car crashes and arrested 25 people for driving under the influence during beefed-up enforcement during the Thanksgiving holiday period.
Extra patrols began early Tuesday morning and will continue through Sunday night.
Troopers say 88 accidents involved injuries and one person died. Police say 29-year-old Luis Contreras of Norwalk was killed Tuesday when his car crashed on Route 7 in Norwalk. The cause of the accident is under investigation.
State police say they're targeting drunken drivers and aggressive drivers.
Troopers say they've issued nearly 890 speeding tickets and nearly 300 tickets for failure to wear seat belts. They've also cited nearly 2,600 drivers for hazardous moving violations including tailgating and illegal cell phone use while driving.
Continue Reading...

November 26, 2014

A new DUI test, in case you’re driving while drugged

Quebec City (Quebec) 25 November 2014 – As if the breathalyser test wasn’t enough, there is a new ‘out to getcha’ gadget to determine whether or not you’re driving under the influence of marijuana, cocaine, heroin or even amphetamines. It’s called Drugwipe or Drugtest and the Federal Government is about to introduce a new amendment to the criminal code to allow the use of the new gadget by police forces across the country.
They are already being used in countries such as Australia and France.
Like the breathalyser, police will be able to stop you and ask to take a sample of your saliva to detect whether or not you have taken some sort of illegal drug while driving. The results are instantaneous, just like the breathalyser, allowing the officer to detain the driver on the spot.
The old method of asking a driver to take a physical test, like walking a straight line or touching your nose with your finger, will become taboo with the new detectors.
The new gadget is not completely flawless leaving the door open for legal battles if the results are not necessarily conclusive.
In most cases however the two devices are infallible and have been found to be very efficient from tests done in Europe.
Other tests are being performed by the RCMP, here in Canada, and the whole idea is being fully supported by the Mothers against Drunk (Drugged) Driving, (MADD) lobbying group.
The new change to the law will be most likely tabled in May 2015. The timing is important because the Liberal Government has said they would legalize marijuana if they were to become the next government.
The NDP would like a clause pertaining to the amount of drugs used by any one individual.
Continue Reading...

North Carolina: Court Denies Lawyer In DUI Blood Draw

North Carolina Appeals Court denies DUI suspect access to a lawyer during a forced blood draw.Several states have begun cracking down on the the practice of drawing blood by force from motorists in light of the US Supreme Court's McNeely decision (view case), but not North Carolina. The state Court of Appeals decided last week that motorists suspected of driving under the influence of alcohol (DUI) may not have access to legal counsel if they are having their blood forcibly drawn pursuant to a search warrant.

Matthew Smith Shepley, a 26-year-old student, was not behind the wheel of a car, or even a motorcycle at 11:30pm on November 22, 2011. Instead, he was pulled over on 20th Street in Buncombe County while riding a scooter with a non-DOT approved helmet. His driving showed no signs of impairment, and he pulled over in his girlfriend's driveway.

During the traffic stop, Deputy Dean Hannah smelled alcohol and took Shepley into custody. At the Buncombe County Detention Center, Officer Travis Jones apprised Shepley of his right under state law to call an attorney and have a witness present for the breath test, and Raquel Harvey arrived to watch. Shepley asked for the breathalyzer machine to be calibrated, but when the officer refused, Shepley said he would not submit to the test.

Officer Jones went to obtain a warrant and ordered Harvey out of the room while Shepley's blood was taken. The State Bureau of Investigation said the result was a blood alcohol content of 0.14. Shepley was convicted and fined $1250, charged $762 in fees and received a sentence of 7 days in prison plus a year of probation on the condition he attend a alcohol treatment program. His driver's license was also suspended. Shepley's public defender appealed on the grounds that the initial stop was invalid, Shepley did not receive a speedy trial, and the drawing of blood without a witness was illegal. The three-judge appellate panel disagreed.

"The plain language of the [witness] statute limits its application to situations in which a defendant consents to take a breathalyzer or other test designated by the officer," Judge Sanford L. Steelman Jr wrote foor the court. "We hold that, because defendant's blood was drawn pursuant to a search warrant obtained after he refused a breath test of his blood alcohol level, he did not have a right under North Carolina General Statutes Section 20-16.2 to have a witness present."

The panel also held that riding a scooter without a DOT-approved helmet was justification for the stop. A copy of the decision is available in a 120k PDF file at the source link below.

Source: PDF File North Carolina v. Shepley (Court of Appeals, State of North Carolina, 11/4/2014)
Continue Reading...

February 12, 2013

Hatboro man sentenced for DUI and hit-and-run

A Hatboro man this week received a 72-hour to six-month jail sentence for a hit-and-run accident involving a pedestrian.

Brian S. Refsnider, 55, of the first block of Barbara Road, pleaded guilty to charges of driving under the influence of alcohol and failing to stop at an accident scene after striking a pedestrian.
 
 
Refsnider, whose license will be suspended for a year, will also have to serve a three-year probation sentence after he completes his parole, pay a $1,000 fine, perform 36 hours of community service and undergo a substance-abuse evaluation and comply with any recommended treatment.

Hatboro police received a call about a reckless driver from a caller who reported that a man driving a black pickup truck that was traveling “all over the roadway” while traveling north on York Road on Feb. 28, 2012, shortly after 3 p.m., according to the complaint.

When police arrived in the area, they learned that the truck had struck a pedestrian in the first block of York Road and continued north without stopping, the complaint said. The pedestrian suffered unspecified minor injuries, according to the police report.

One of the witnesses provided police with the truck’s license plate number that authorities traced to Refsnider.

Arriving at Refsnider’s home, police found Refsnider either asleep or passed out in the driver’s seat of the truck that was parked in the driveway, the complaint said. An open bottle of vodka was found in his pocket, according to the complaint.

Refsnider said he was not aware that his truck had struck a pedestrian.
A test indicated that Refsnider had a blood alcohol concentration of 0.430, according to court documents. This is more than five times the legal limit of 0.08 percent.
Continue Reading...

Hatboro man sentenced for DUI, hit-and-run

A Hatboro man this week received a 72-hour to six-month jail sentence for a hit-and-run accident involving a pedestrian.
Brian S. Refsnider, 55, of the first block of Barbara Road, pleaded guilty to charges of driving under the influence of alcohol and failing to stop at an accident scene after striking a pedestrian.
 
 
Refsnider, whose license will be suspended for a year, will also have to serve a three-year probation sentence after he completes his parole, pay a $1,000 fine, perform 36 hours of community service and undergo a substance-abuse evaluation and comply with any recommended treatment.

Hatboro police received a call about a reckless driver from a caller who reported that a man driving a black pickup truck that was traveling “all over the roadway” while traveling north on York Road on Feb. 28, 2012, shortly after 3 p.m., according to the complaint.

When police arrived in the area, they learned that the truck had struck a pedestrian in the first block of York Road and continued north without stopping, the complaint said. The pedestrian suffered unspecified minor injuries, according to the police report.

One of the witnesses provided police with the truck’s license plate number that authorities traced to Refsnider.

Arriving at Refsnider’s home, police found Refsnider either asleep or passed out in the driver’s seat of the truck that was parked in the driveway, the complaint said. An open bottle of vodka was found in his pocket, according to the complaint.

Refsnider said he was not aware that his truck had struck a pedestrian.
A test indicated that Refsnider had a blood alcohol concentration of 0.430, according to court documents. This is more than five times the legal limit of 0.08 percent.
Continue Reading...

English football star Gascoigne enters treatment while Grace begins DUI sentence

Retired Arizona Diamondbacks star Mark Grace entered the Lower Buckeye Jail yesterday to begin a four-month sentence for DUI following his second arrest last August.
And Saturday night, retired English football (soccer to us Yanks) star Paul Gascoigne continued his lifelong struggle with mental illness and alcoholism in Tucson's Cottonwood treatment center.
Grace's August arrest was not only for extreme DUI but also for failing to use the interlock device put in place after his first DUI arrest in May 2011. He also lost his license for the stipulated 90 days. The Diamondbacks fired him from his broadcaster job, but recently hired him to coach the team's minor leaguers. Under his plea bargain, he will be allowed to participate in work-release, but will return to jail each night.

After the four months, Grace will be on probation for two years during which time he will no doubt be compelled to continue alcohol treatment.

According to his website, Grace has "embraced" sobriety. In a video on the site, he puts the blame for his situation squarely on himself--("I got nobody to blame but myself")--and repeatedly thanks the Diamondbacks for their "class" in inviting him back as a coach. He says he's getting lots of support from former campers who have attended his baseball camps, former teammates, the Diamondbacks themselves, and fans. "It's been awesome," Grace says over and over.
Gascoigne is a beloved name among fans of European football. His career sets him as one of England's best footballers, having won the FA (Football Association) Cup with the Tottenham Hotspurs (link provided to prove I'm not making up this name), and has played on England's national team as well. You can compare him to, say, (swallow) Tom Brady or Mark Warner. Or heck, two-time Super Bowl champ Eli Manning.

Gascoigne has struggled with mental health issues all his life, and with alcoholism at least since the beginning of his career. He has been hospitalized countless times for alcohol and mental health treatment as well as physical ailments including pneumonia and a perforated stomach ulcer. At least one mental health hospitalization was compelled by England's Mental Health Act after an incident in which police judged he was a danger to himself and others. (The Arizona Legislature is now considering a similar bill.) He admitted to domestic violence in two autobiographies.
This weekend, Gascoigne's friends in England--a few former teammates and entertainers including Piers Morgan--pooled their money to send him to Cottonwood for more specialized treatment. Cottonwood treats alcoholism along with co-morbid, or commonly seen, disorders that Gascoigne is said to have, including bipolar disorder, bulimia, and gambling. Detox so far has been so tough that Gascoigne entered in intensive care upon arrival; he is now said to be out of danger.
Judging by comments I've read in some English newspapers, the British public is fairly sympathetic to "Gazza's" troubles and include interesting debates about whether treatment can work.
Not so the comments I'm reading on Phoenix news sites. I hope fans will show some restraint toward Grace, if not shout out some encouragement, during the upcoming spring training games.
Good luck, mates.
Continue Reading...

How long can you get for a Felony DUI?

Sarah asked me a question about DUI: How long can you get for a Felony DUI?
More precisely:
"My friend was arrested for a first offense DUI and there was property damage involved. He has no license and he also resisted arrest. My question is, how much time will he get? This is in the state of California."

The answer should be following:
It depends if it is your first DUI. If it's a felony and not your first DUI, then you can get up to 60 days in jail. My second DUI was a felony and I got 35 days in jail.

Best regards,
Peter Drill
Continue Reading...

Booming stereo leads to DUI charges in Berwyn

BERWYN – Loud music coming from a vehicle resulted in a driving under the influence of alcohol charge in Berwyn at 1:24 a.m. Feb. 4, according to police reports.

Police responding to a report of loud music found David L. Pachuca, 29, of 6530 W. Sinclair Ave., Berwyn, sitting in his car in front of the home with the stereo at high volume, police said.
A can of beer allegedly was seen in the console of the car as well as several empty beer cans on the floor. Pachuca allegedly was slurring his speech and appeared intoxicated, according to police reports.

He also was charged with illegal operation of a sound amplification system, driving without insurance and having open alcohol in a vehicle, police said.
Continue Reading...

Husband and wife arrested for DUI following hit-and-run accident

A husband and wife were jailed Sunday on charges of drunken driving after leaving the scene of an accident.

Kimberly Jo Kershaw, 33, appeared Monday in Scotts Bluff County Court; however, her husband, Jeremiah Kershaw, 35, appeared to have bonded out of jail. Kimberly Kershaw has been charged with driving under the influence with a blood-alcohol content over .15, second offense, and leaving the scene of an accident.


Jeremiah Kershaw, who has not been formally charged, had been arrested on charges of driving under the influence, third offense; refusal to submit to chemical tests and refusal to submit to a preliminary breath test; possession of an open container and seat belt violation.
According to court documents in both cases, the Nebraska State Patrol and Scotts Bluff County Sheriff’s Office were called to a hit and run accident on county road 15 at about 10 p.m. Sunday. A responding trooper found that a driver had struck a fence post and left the scene of the accident. A Nebraska state Patrol trooper stopped a Chevy vehicle in the area of the accident with a broken headlight and damage to its grill.
Kimberly Kershaw admitted she had been driving the vehicle, but that she had switched places with Jeremiah Kershaw. Jeremiah Kershaw left the scene of the accident and had been driving at the time that the trooper pulled the vehicle over.
The trooper found an open beer can in a cup holder of the vehicle. Both Kimberly Kershaw and Jeremiah Kershaw were arrested and jailed at the Scotts Bluff County Detention Center. Jeremiah Kershaw posted bond on Monday and did not appear in court.

Continue Reading...

August 22, 2011

Montco Towns - DUI checkpoints number increase

Due to Labor Day, Montgomery County towns — including Abington,  Upper Dublin, Cheltenham and Jenkintown — will increase DUI checkpoints soon after acquiring federal funds, according to the Pennsylvania Department of Transportation.
In the cooperation with all the “Drive Sober or Get Pulled Over” initiative, 36 local police departments — and 600 statewide — will  "conduct roving patrols and checkpoints targeting motorists helped by the influence of drugs or alcohol," in keeping with a PennDOT press release.  Statewide enforcement shall be upped and PennDOT officials encourage individual municipalities to wave is border-to-border enforcement.
“People can have end-of-summer plans which entail alcohol, but safety is to be along at the forefront of everyone’s mind,” PennDOT Secretary Barry J. Schoch said. “Getting in the area of the wheel when you’re impaired by drugs or alcohol puts your life in peril, as well as the lives of everyone sharing an open road on you. Do everyone a favor by designating a driver.”
PennDOT distributed $4.2 million in federal funds from the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. A little while ago, there are 169 alcohol-related crashes and five fatalities during Labor Day weekend in 2010.
Continue Reading...

August 11, 2011

What does DWI mean?

Many of you who have heard a word DWI first time, have asked yourself what does DWI mean? DWI means a specific criminal offense: Driving While Intoxicated. There is a lot of others states like DUI, which means Driving under influence, operating while impaired (OWI) and (OVI) operating a vehicle under the influence. Driving while intoxicated is common offense in US. Ohio began to issue special license plates to DUI offenders in 1967.

Continue Reading...

March 1, 2011

The Next Step in “The War on Drunk Driving”?

I suppose it was inevitable….


Passengers Get Prison Terms in Fatal Drunk Driving Accident

Saitama, Japan.  Feb. 15 — Two men were sentenced to two years in prison Monday for abetting a fatal traffic accident caused by another man who had given the pair

a ride in his car after drinking alcohol in Kumagaya, Saitama Prefecture, in 2008.

The Saitama District Court ruled that the two men’s consent to the third man’s offer to give them a lift had encouraged him to drive, despite their obligation to stop him

from getting behind the wheel while under the influence…

In the ruling, presiding Judge Makoto Tamura said the two men’s acceptance of the driver’s offer after drinking together had helped him to decide to drive.

Prosecutors had demanded eight years’ imprisonment for both. Oshima and Sekiguchi had pleaded innocent during their trial.

The focus of the trial was whether the pair were aware that the driver had been intoxicated at the time, and whether they had turned a blind eye to his drunken driving…


Guess what Mothers Against Drunk Driving’s next brilliant idea will be to end drunk driving driving?


View the original article here

Continue Reading...

February 24, 2011

Attorney General Finds Widespread Breathalyzer Inaccuracies; Police Shut Down All Machines

If you are accused of DUI or DWI, a reading results in a legal presumption of guilt; if charged with driving with a blood-alcohol content of .08% or higher, the machine is the only evidence of blood-alcohol.  In essence, either way you will be facing a "trial by machine".

So how good are these machines?  Good enough to constitute "proof beyond a reasonable doubt"?  Or are they just "close enough for government work"?

As regular readers know, one of my pet peeves is the unreliability and inaccuracy of breathalyzers (or, more accurately, any of the various breath testing models sold by a handful of manufacturers).  See, for example, Breath Alcohol Testing: "State of the Art?, Why Breathalyzers Don’t Measure Alcohol and Report: Breathalyzers Outdated, Unstable, Unreliable. 

D.C. Attorney General Drops Drunk Driving Cases

Wash. DC.  Feb. 8 — The District’s attorney general has dropped dozens of drunken driving cases since Jan. 31 and hundreds of others could be dropped as the police department shuts down its troubled alcohol breath-test program. Problems dating back more than three years with the city’s breath analyzers were first revealed in February 2010, when it was discovered the machines’ results were inaccurate. Since then, the D.C. medical examiner’s office has refused to sign off on the accuracy tests of new analysis machines, officials said.

"The alcohol breath-analysis program? It doesn’t exist anymore," said Ilmar Paegle, who discovered problems with the Intoxilyzer 5000s soon after he took over the city’s breath-analysis program on Feb. 1, 2010. Paegle’s contract ended last week. As he left, he said, the police department pulled off the street the Intoximeter, which replaced the Intoxilyzer last spring. "It’s a royal mess," Paegle said.

A spokeswoman for D.C. Attorney General Irvin Nathan said he couldn’t be pulled from a meeting to comment Tuesday. Nathan dropped eight more drunken driving cases Tuesday.

City policy requires the medical examiner’s office to certify the program, and it has not done so, citing concerns raised by the problems with the previous models, Paegle said. Although officers had been using the Intoximeters, the results were not being included as evidence, according to Paegle and internal police e-mails obtained by The Washington Examiner.

The medical examiner’s office declined to comment, citing pending litigation. Dozens of defendants have sued the city after being convicted on potentially faulty breath-test results.

Assistant police Chief Patrick Burke said officers are now taking urine samples to test blood alcohol levels for potential future prosecutions.

Meanwhile, the two police officers who account for a third of the city’s 1,400 annual drunken driving arrests have had their trial testimony called into question. They are the subjects of an internal affairs investigation that began after they spoke out about problems with the breath analyzers.

Officers Jose Rodriguez and Andrew Zabavsky learned that the medical examiner hadn’t signed off on the program and began mentioning that in their trial testimony last spring, according to an e-mail from Zabavsky to police Chief Cathy Lanier. Later in the spring, the attorney general’s office began an investigation into the officers, saying a woman they arrested for driving under the influence in June 2009 had complained the two watched her take a urine test.

In December, the case was turned over to internal affairs.

"On a day-by-day basis, cases are being dismissed because the officers involved are being investigated," said defense lawyer Bryan Brown.

The result, police union chief Kris Baumann said, is "our ability to enforce DUI laws in the District has been crippled".


The breathalyzers involved are the most commonly used across the country.  Do you really think only those in Washington D.C. are giving false results? 


View the original article here

Continue Reading...

February 23, 2011

The Metamorphosis of a Crime

Drunk driving is bad.  It’s potentially dangerous to human life.  It should be punished.  So, many years ago a law was passed: 

"Thou shalt not drive drunk."

It was a fair law and it addressed the problem.  So…what happened?  Why do today’s laws punish drivers when they are neither "drunk" nor "driving" — nor even in a "vehicle"? 

"Drunk"

The original laws prohibited driving a vehicle "under the influence of alcohol" — commonly referred to as "DUI".  In some states, it’s called "DWI" (driving while intoxicated) or "OUI" (operating under the influence).  In other words, the accused had to be (1) driving (2) a vehicle (3) while intoxicated to the extent that he or she was unable to safely operate it.

This changed a few years ago with the passage of so-called per se laws.  Prosecutors and groups like MADD were frustrated with the difficulties in proving that a driver was, in fact, under the influence.  So legislators, anxious for re-election endorsements from prosecutors, police and MADD, passed a new law:

"Thou shalt not drive with a blood alcohol level of .10% or more."

Well, this made it much, much easier to convict citizens suspected of drunk driving.  First, prosecutors no longer had to prove that a driver was impaired in his judgment, reflexes, perception and coordination.  All they had to do was produce a number: .10%.  Never mind that the American Medical Association conducted studies and announced in 1938 that a driver was only "impaired" at .15%.  Never mind that MADD was later successful in getting the number reduced further down to .08% (and is lobbying for further reduction to .05%).  And never mind that every person’s tolerance to alcohol varies widely — that some drivers may be under the influence at .07%, while others may not be intoxicated at .11%.  The law was no longer interested in whether the driver was a danger or not: the crime was in having alcohol in your body.

The second reason the new per se laws were wildly popular with prosecutors, police and MADD was that the arrested citizen could now be charged with both crimes — DUIand .08%.  This had two big advantages.  First, it gave the prosecutor two shots at the defendant; if he didn’t get him for one, he might get him for the other.  Second, it gave juries that were unsure of the defendant’s guilt an option: convict him of one charge but acquit him of the other.  Juries that were not unanimous could use this as a compromise — even if some jurors felt the accused was not really proven guilty.

Just to make it even easier, many courts have followed the California Supreme Court in ruling that the breath alcohol reading cannot be questioned on the grounds that it does not accurately reflect the alcohol actually in the person’s blood.  See Bransford v. California.  (One dissenting justice in that case, less concerned with politics than with common sense, wrote: "The majority…has on its own created the new crime of driving with alcohol in one’s breath.")


"Driving" 

The second half of drunk driving is…"driving".  This would seem obvious: how can you be driving under the influence if you’re not…well, driving?

No problem.  If you have judges who do not want opposition from prosecutors, police and MADD at the next election, you will have strange judicial interpretations of what "driving" means.  And in recent years there has been a flood of judicial interpretations which have stretched the word beyond recognition.  A couple of examples:

Sleeping in (or near) the car.  See my posts Sleeping Under the Influence, How to "Drive" Under the Influence While Sleeping, Convicted of Drunk Driving Without Driving and When Does the Insanity End?

Sitting in a parked car.  See Parking Under the Influence and Sitting in a Parked Car  


"Vehicle"

Just as the judges stretched the meaning of "driving" beyond the limits of credulity, so they also expanded the definition of what constituted a "vehicle".  Now, a "vehicle" is commonly understood to mean a car or truck, and so it has been applied for decades.  But this, too, has been slowly expanded to include such "vehicles" as:

Bicycles.  See my posts DUI on Bicycles, Felony DUI Bicycle and DUI While Walking a Bicycle

Lawnmowers.  See More News From the Front and The "War on Drunk Driving" Marches On

Horses. See DUI on a Horse

Wheelchairs.  See DUI in a Wheelchair

Toy bikes.  See DUI on a Foot-High Toy Bike 

Golf carts.  See The War on Drunk Driving Continues

Zamboni ice machines.  See News From the Front


As Humpty Dumpty explained to Alice so many years ago:


"When I use a word”, Humpty Dumpty said, in a rather scornful tone, “it means just what I choose it to mean — neither more nor less.”

“The question is”, said Alice,”whether you can make words mean so many different things.”

“The question is”, said Humpty Dumpty, “which is to be master — that’s all.”


We used to have laws punishing drunk drivers. They were good laws, designed to protect citizens.  Whatever happened to them?


View the original article here

Continue Reading...

February 6, 2011

Women and Breathalyzers

If you are arrested for DUI and a breath test shows a blood alcohol concentration (BAC) of .08% or higher, you are presumed guilty. It does not matter, of course, whether you are a man or a women: the laws do not discriminate.

Maybe they should…

Researchers at the University School of Medicine in Trieste, Italy, have found that the stomach lining contains an enzyme called gastric alcohol dehydrogenase that breaks down alcohol, and that women have less of this enzyme than men.

To determine the relative effects of the enzyme, they gave alcohol both orally and intravenously to groups of alcoholic and non-alcoholic men and women. They found that women reached the same levels of blood alcohol as men after drinking only half as much.  With weight differences taken into account, they found that women reached BAC levels illegal in a DUI case after drinking 20 to 30 percent less alcohol than men.

The scientists’ conclusion: legislatures may need to consider sex differences in drunk driving laws when defining safe levels of drinking for driving motor vehicles. Frezza and Lieber, "High Blood Alcohol Levels in Women: The Role of Decreased Gastric Alcohol Dehydrogenase Activity and First-Pass Metabolism", 322(2) New England Journal of Medicine 95 (1990).

Yet another study has found that women have lower partition ratios of blood to breath. What kind of ratios? Well, all breath machines in DUI cases measure the amount of alcohol in a person’s breath. But the what we really want to know is the amount of alcohol in the person’s blood. So how do we get that? Simple: a small computer in the Breathalyzer multiplies the amount of alcohol it detects in the breath sample by 2100 times.

This is based upon the theory that, on average, there are 2100 units of alcohol in the blood for every unit of alcohol in the breath.  Of course, that’s only an average:  it varies from person to person.) According to the study, women have a significantly lower partition ratio. Jones, "Determination of Liquid/Air Partition Coefficients for Dilute Solutions of Ethanol in Water, Whole Blood and Plasma", Analytical Toxicology 193 (July/August 1983).  And the lower the partition ratio, the higher the reading — even though the true BAC does not vary. For example, a woman with a true BAC of .06% — below the legal limit — and a ratio of 1500:1 (rather than the presumed 2100:1) will get a reading on the machine of .09% — above the legal limit.

Put another way, the breath machine will show an average man accused of drunk driving to be innocent — but a woman with the same blood alcohol level to be guilty.

And then there’s the problem of birth control….

Scientists in Canada have found that "women taking oral contraceptive steroids (O.C.S.) appeared to eliminate ethanol significantly faster than women not taking O.C.S."  Papple, "The Effects of Oral Contraceptive Steroids on the Rate of Post-Absorptive Phase Decline of Blood Alcohol Concentration in the Adult Woman", 15(1) Canadian Society of Forensic Science Journal 17 (1982).

That means that women will reach peak BAC faster, and return to lower levels more quickly. This, of course, can create serious problems in a DUI case when attempting to estimate BAC at the time of driving based upon a breath test administered one or two hours later.

Making the problem worse, researchers have also discovered that women who were taking birth control pills or who were pregnant had higher levels of acetaldehyde on their breath, due to the decreased ability to metabolize the enzyme as the level of sex steroids increases.

So what?

Well, most breath machines use infrared analysis in measuring the breath sample of a DUI suspect. But these machines don’t really measure alcohol, rather they measure any compound which contains the methyl group in its molecular structure — and simply assumes that it is alcohol. And acetaldehyde is one of these compounds. Result: a higher "blood alcohol" reading on the Breathalyzer. Jeavons and Zeiner, "Effects of Elevated Female Sex Steroids on Ethanol and Acetaldehyde Metabolism in Humans", 8(4) Alcoholism: Clinical and Experimental Research 352 (1984).

It’s always a problem when the law, in its infinite wisdom, assumes that all of us are exactly the same.  (See How to Convict an Average Man)


View the original article here

Continue Reading...

February 5, 2011

Close Enough for Government Work

How crazy have things gotten in MADD’s "war on drunk driving"? 


Court: Key Enough for Drunk Driving Conviction

Boston, MA.  Jan. 25 — The state Appeals Court has ruled that someone who inserts a key in a car’s ignition and turns on the vehicle’s electricity without starting the engine can be convicted of drunken driving.

Robert S. McGillivary of Salisbury appealed his 2007 drunken driving conviction on the grounds that he was not operating the vehicle when an officer found him slumped over the steering wheel with the key in the ignition and the dashboard illuminated.

The court said Tuesday that turning the key is the first step in a sequence to set the vehicle in motion and "was sufficient to permit the jury to conclude that he ’operated’ the motor vehicle."


So…if you point a gun at someone, you’re guilty of murder?

There may be some logic to charging attempted drunk driving for putting a key in the ignition and then falling asleep, but it’s a corruption of the legal system to pretend that the crime actually took place.  

Unfortunately, this kind of legal and legislative corruption is common in the DUI arena.  See, for example, The DUI Exception to the Constitution.


View the original article here

Continue Reading...

January 26, 2011

Driving Under the Influence of…Binaca?

So you’re driving along and suddenly there are flashing red lights in your rear view mirror. You recall that glass of wine with dinner: not nearly enough to be over .08%, of course, but enough to cause an odor of alcohol on the breath. As you pull over, you grab the breath freshener and quickly spray it into your mouth. The officer asks you to step out of the car, holds out a portable breath testing device and asks you to blow into it. A moment later you are being handcuffed.

What happened? One of the many problems with breath machines is that they cannot tell the difference between alcohol coming from the lungs and alcohol which is already in the mouth or throat. This problem is referred to as mouth alcohol, and is particularly troublesome because, believing it to be alcohol from the lungs, the breath machines will incorrectly multiply the detected alcohol by 2100 times (see my earlier post, Breathalyzers — and Why They Don’t Work).

One common source of breath alcohol is breath spray, as well as mouthwash — both of which contain significant amounts of alcohol. Listerine, for example, contains 27% alcohol, Scope 19% and Astring-O-Sol 76%. Even a tiny amount of this on the breath or in the throat, if multiplied by the machine 2100 times, can result in high breathalyzer readings.

This was clearly illustrated in a study conducted with Listerine mouthwash on a breath machine and reported in an article entitled "Field Sobriety Testing: Intoxilyzers and Listerine Antiseptic", published in the July 1985 issue of The Police Chief . Seven alcohol-free individuals were tested at a police station, with readings of .00%. Each then rinsed his mouth with 20 milliliters of Listerine mouthwash for 30 seconds in accordance with directions on the label. All seven were then tested on the machine at intervals of one, three, five and ten minutes.

The results indicated an average reading of .43% blood-alcohol concentration — indicating a level that, if accurate, approached lethal proportions. After three minutes, the average level was still .20%, despite the absence of any alcohol in the system. Even after five minutes, the average level was .11% — well over the legal limit.

In another study, reported in 8(22) Drinking/Driving Law Letter 1, a scientist tested the effects of Binaca breath spray on an Intoxilyzer 5000. He performed 23 tests with subjects who sprayed their throats, and obtained readings as high as .81% — far beyond lethal levels. The scientist also noted that the effects of the spray did not fall below detectable levels until after 18 minutes.

Don’t spray and drive.


View the original article here

Continue Reading...

Links

Developed in partnership with SanFran Coders.

Blogroll

The acronyms DUI, DWI, OMVI and OVI all refer to the same thing: operating a vehicle under the influence of alcohol or drugs. The most commonly used terms are DUI, an acronym for Driving Under the Influence, and DWI, an acronym for Driving While Impaired.
© Copyright 2010 - 2015 MY OVI | Developed by San Fran Coders